Serving Idaho, Utah, and Wyoming

Talk to an expert:  208-522-5151   |

The Utah Insurance Fraud Ring: A $20 Million Scam That Rocked the Beehive State

by | Apr 18, 2023

While insurance fraud may not always reach the scale of multi-billion-dollar schemes, even smaller-scale operations can significantly impact their communities. One such case occurred in Utah, where a group of individuals orchestrated a complex insurance fraud ring that resulted in over $20 million in false claims. In this blog post, we’ll delve into the details of this massive scam and its repercussions on the Beehive State.

The Scheme:

In the early 2000s, a group of individuals, led by a man named Merritt Taylor Jenson, began an intricate insurance fraud scheme in Utah. The operation involved staging car accidents and submitting false insurance claims for medical treatments, lost wages, and property damage. The group would enlist “runners” to recruit accident participants, who would then receive a portion of the insurance payouts.

Over several years, the ring is believed to have staged more than 300 accidents and filed more than 2,000 false insurance claims, totaling over $20 million in fraudulent payouts. The scam targeted multiple insurance companies and impacted premiums for honest policyholders throughout the state.

The Investigation:

The Utah Insurance Fraud Division (UIFD) began investigating the case in 2004 after noticing numerous suspicious claims. With the help of the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) and local law enforcement, the UIFD built a case against the fraud ring, uncovering the vast network of participants and the extent of the operation.

The Takedown:

In 2006, authorities arrested Merritt Taylor Jenson and several other key fraud ring members. The operation was dismantled, and over 60 individuals were charged with various crimes, including insurance fraud, racketeering, and money laundering.

In the following years, many participants received prison sentences, probation, and hefty fines and restitution orders. The case served as a wake-up call for insurance companies and regulators in Utah, leading to increased efforts to detect and prevent insurance fraud in the state.

We’re Here for You

The Utah insurance fraud ring is a prime example of how even a relatively localized scam can have wide-ranging consequences for policyholders and the insurance industry. At Page Insurance, we are committed to upholding the highest standards of integrity and providing our clients with the best possible insurance solutions. If you have questions about your coverage or need assistance finding the right policy, don’t hesitate to contact us. We’re here to help!

Get quotes here.


John Page, President of Page Insurance, has been a driving force in the insurance industry since 1999. As a licensed agent in Property & Casualty, Life, and Health insurance, John has won numerous awards for agency management and works tirelessly to improve agency operations with the client in mind. He is passionate about building and investing in the Page team of experts, ensuring they deliver top-notch service to clients. In his free time, John enjoys snowmobiling, gaming, reading, traveling with his wife and three kids, and cheering on the local Idaho Falls hockey team.